If you want them to shop locally, you have to market locally
Thursday, August 5th, 2010A friend of mine is in charge of her needlework guild’s membership address book. Her responsibilities include calling local shops to see whether they will offer a member discount through the year. If they do, they receive a free mention in the book.
As in past years, this was mostly just a courtesy call — the majority of shops welcomed the free exposure. But this year, she encountered two shop owners who verbally took her to task for members not coming in.
One just vented her frustration, which, while perhaps unprofessional, was at least understandable.
The other told her, “Forget it. No one came in, and maybe they’ll notice if I don’t give a discount this year.”
My friend was not asking for a paid renewal, in which case I could see the owner declining. She was asking to rerun a free ad in a local guild membership address book — a highly targeted market. The owner didn’t even have to submit anything; her ad was already on file.
When my friend told me about this, she also noted that she knew of at least four of her fellow members who had been in that particular shop in recent months. When she mentioned that to the owner during their conversation, the woman sniffed, “Two, maybe.”
Whether it was four, two or one, doesn’t every customer count? And if “no one” was coming in, what was it costing her? The 10% discount she wasn’t giving to anyone?
I see four ways where wine could have been made with these sour grapes, if only the owner could get past her pride:
- She was missing an opportunity to get valuable feedback, to ask my friend, “Do you know why more members aren’t coming in?” It could have less to do with price and more to do with shop hours or parking availability. While these may not be easily fixed, they’re at least tangible issues to address.
- Had she attended a guild function as a guest, to mix with members and build relationships, she might have garnered some interest. Think of how many networking event converations end in “Send me your email address” or “Stop by the shop” or “Let me call you next week.”
- Had she offered to speak to the guild about an area of expertise, she could have positioned herself as a local expert and thus the “go-to” person when a member was looking for what her shop offers.
- If a discount program wasn’t bringing them in, perhaps a frequent shopper program would. Maybe a referral program would grab attention (Forbes recently published a great article about this). I guess you could say she was “switching strategies” by dropping the free ad, but her abrupt manner sabotaged any customer relations she was looking to build. Bottom line: If one method isn’t working, switch gears gracefully. Don’t just grab your marbles and go home.
By the actions she did take, the owner ended up getting brand exposure — just not the kind any business owner wants. My friend has told her story to all her local and non-local friends, and inevitably receives the same surprised reaction.
“Maybe they’ll notice if I don’t give a discount this year”? How self-defeating. Why would they notice, when they’re going to the competitors who appear in the book and whose shops are top of mind?


